Get Schooled: Email Scorecard for A+ Campaigns

💣 Knowledge Bombs

We're giving you the scorecard so you always know where your email marketing program stands, and we're setting the bar for excellence where everybody can see it, strive for it, and achieve it.
Get Schooled: The Anatomy of a Marketing Email

We’ve all had a teacher in our lifetime who handed out grades with next-to-no justification.

Erica got a B- in her college speech class and other far-less-skilled public speakers got B+s and As. And when she pressed the teacher on why she hadn’t been given a higher grade, he told her it was because she had started strong but didn’t improve much over the course of the quarter.

And while at the time she didn’t love his justification, Erica can now appreciate the importance of tracking performance so you aren’t just resting on your laurels or your natural talent or your inherited healthy email list.

Today, we’re giving you the scorecard so you always know where your email marketing program stands, and we’re setting the bar for excellence where everybody can see it, strive for it, and achieve it.

You Want an A+ Email Marketing Campaign?

Teacher Erica is about to show you the scorecard!

It’s show and tell time in the Email Mavens classroom, and this lesson is a demonstration: even if you’re normally a reader, you’ll want to watch the class recording, where Erica shows you exactly how we track campaign performance on a monthly basis.

When you’re ready to act on what your scorecard tells you, start with three email A/B tests to run this month. And keep going with the Get Schooled series: the anatomy of a marketing email, then the finale, how to dream.

Keep pressing send on your next best email!

Erica Walter, Founder + CEO at Email Mavens

Erica Walter · Founder + CEO, Email Mavens

Erica has spent nearly two decades in winery email marketing and has opinions about subject lines. She teaches wineries to send marketing emails that sell (that don't suck).

Reading is a great start. Watching Erica build the systems is even better. The masterclass is free.

Keep Pouring

Is your Winery Email Marketing Ready for the Holidays?
Email Strategy
· Oct 8, 2026

Before Black Friday | Winery Holiday Email Checklist

Your best seasonal offer won’t save a shaky sending system. See what to inspect now, before the rush turns a small problem into a very public one.

Read the post →

Erica Walter beside the title “Winery Email Marketing Has Changed. Here’s What Matters Now.”
Email Strategy
· Sep 30, 2026

Winery Email Marketing Has Changed. Here’s What Matters Now.

I revisited the PRESS SEND framework with a slightly terrifying question: does this thing still hold up? The answer relieved me, but it also raised my expectations for your winery's email program.

Read the post →

Erica Walter answering wine club email marketing questions for Email Mavens
Email Strategy
· Sep 10, 2026

Your Questions, Answered | Wine Club Email Marketing

Wine club pros brought the questions, and Erica brought the correct opinions. See what she had to say about member relationships and smarter tech choices.

Read the post →